Plano Water Quality & Filtration Guide

Introduction To Water Quality in Plano

Plano, Texas receives its drinking water primarily from surface water sources managed by the North Texas Municipal Water District (NTMWD), serving approximately 277,720 residents. While Plano's water utility has met all federal compliance standards in recent assessments, deeper analysis reveals concerning levels of several contaminants that exceed recommended health guidelines.

Plano's water infrastructure draws from multiple sources including:

• Lavon Lake (primary source, treated at Wylie Water Treatment Plant)
• Lake Texoma
• East Fork Water Reuse Project
• Jim Chapman Lake
• Lake Tawakoni
• Bois d'Arc Lake (completed in 2022)

A significant component of Plano's water supply comes from the innovative East Fork Water Reuse Project, one of Texas's largest water reuse systems. This system diverts approximately 91 million gallons daily of effluent-dominated water from the Trinity River's East Fork, processes it through a 2,000-acre constructed wetland, and pumps the treated water to Lavon Lake to supplement the district's surface water supply.

Despite meeting federal standards, Plano's water contains multiple contaminants at levels that raise health concerns, particularly disinfection byproducts, chromium-6, and detectable lead levels. Understanding these contaminants and their potential health impacts is crucial for Plano residents concerned about their water quality.

Contaminants and Pollutants in your Local Water

Analysis of Plano's municipal water supply has identified several concerning contaminants that exceed health guidelines established by environmental and research organizations:

• Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs): The most significant water quality concerns in Plano, with some compounds detected at levels hundreds of times above health guidelines
  • Haloacetic acids (HAA9): 539 times above EWG's Health Guideline
  • Bromochloroacetic acid: 390 times above recommended limits
  • Dichloroacetic acid: 61 times above health guidelines
  • Bromoform: 4.3 times above recommended levels
  • Bromate: 2.8 times above health guidelines
  • Chlorate: 2.5 times above recommended limits
  • Total trihalomethanes (TTHMs): Moderate maximum of 62.1 ppb
• Heavy Metals and Minerals
  • Chromium-6: Averaging 120 parts per trillion, approximately 6 times higher than concentrations determined to have a negligible cancer risk
  • Lead: 90th percentile concentration of 3 parts per billion
  • Fluoride: Present in decreasing trends (0.807 ppm in 2014 to 0.222 ppm in 2019)
• PFAS Compounds
  • Perfluorononanoic acid (PFNA): No detections in 2014-2015 testing

For private well owners in the Plano area who draw from local aquifers rather than municipal supplies, additional concerns include increasing salinity and natural salt contamination, particularly in the Trinity Aquifer system.

Explanation of Contaminants and their Problems

Disinfection Byproducts (DBPs)

Disinfection byproducts form when disinfectants like chlorine react with naturally occurring organic matter in water. Plano's water contains concerning levels of multiple DBPs, with some exceeding health guidelines by hundreds of times.

Long-term exposure to these compounds is associated with:

• Increased cancer risk across multiple organ systems
• Potential reproductive problems and pregnancy complications
• DNA damage in cellular structures
• Developmental concerns for fetuses and young children

Haloacetic acids and trihalomethanes, two major categories of DBPs found in Plano's water, are particularly concerning due to their established links to bladder cancer and potentially other cancers with prolonged exposure.

The East Fork Water Reuse Project, while innovative for water conservation, may contribute to higher levels of organic matter in source water, potentially increasing DBP formation during disinfection processes.

Chromium-6 (Hexavalent Chromium)

Chromium-6, a known carcinogen made famous by the Erin Brockovich case, exists in Plano's water at levels approximately 6 times higher than concentrations associated with negligible cancer risk.

Health concerns associated with chromium-6 exposure include:

• Increased risk of gastrointestinal tumors
• Reproductive system damage
• Liver and kidney damage
• Asthma and respiratory issues
• Compromised immune system function

While conventional total chromium testing showed fluctuating or undetectable levels between 2014-2019, specific chromium-6 testing revealed the concerning 120 parts per trillion average. This discrepancy highlights why total chromium measurements are unreliable indicators of the more toxic hexavalent form.

Lead

While Plano's lead levels (90th percentile concentration of 3 ppb) comply with federal standards, health experts emphasize that no level of lead is considered safe, particularly for vulnerable populations.

Lead exposure, even at low levels, can cause:

• Developmental delays and cognitive impairment in children
• Behavioral problems and reduced IQ
• Cardiovascular effects and increased blood pressure in adults
• Kidney dysfunction
• Reproductive problems in both men and women

Lead typically enters drinking water through older lead service pipes and lead-containing plumbing materials rather than from source water, making it a particular concern for older homes in Plano.

Fluoride

Fluoride is present in Plano's water, though levels have decreased over time from 0.807 ppm in 2014 to 0.222 ppm in 2019. While fluoride is added to many water supplies to promote dental health, excessive exposure can lead to:

• Dental fluorosis (discoloration and pitting of tooth enamel)
• Skeletal fluorosis in cases of very high exposure
• Potential thyroid function impacts
• Possible neurological effects at higher concentrations

Current fluoride levels in Plano remain within recommended ranges for dental benefits without significant health concerns.

Deep Dive on Well Water Quality in the Area

Trinity Aquifer Water Quality

For Plano residents using private wells rather than municipal water, the Trinity Aquifer is the primary groundwater source. This extensive aquifer system extends through 61 North Texas counties and presents its own set of water quality challenges.

The Trinity Aquifer consists of:

• Twin Mountains, Glen Rose, Paluxy, Hosston, and Hensell formations
• In some areas, the Antlers Formation where Glen Rose formation is absent
• Lower, more permeable sections that produce the greatest groundwater

Water quality in the Trinity Aquifer presents growing concerns:

• Increasing salinity levels, particularly in heavily pumped areas
• Natural salt pollution affecting the upper reaches of the Red and Brazos river basins
• Gradual deterioration that has rendered some water unsuitable for domestic use
• Heavy irrigation demands (94% of total use in 2008) stressing the system

Private well owners in Plano face different challenges than municipal water users, with salinity and mineral content being primary concerns rather than disinfection byproducts. Regular testing is essential as aquifer conditions continue to change, particularly in response to regional drought conditions and increasing groundwater demands.

Filtration Recommendations for Plano

Based on Plano's specific contaminant profile, a multi-stage filtration approach is recommended to address both municipal water and private well concerns.

For Municipal Water Users

Activated Carbon FiltrationHigh-quality carbon block filtration effectively reduces many disinfection byproducts, addressing Plano's most significant water quality concern. This technology:

• Reduces haloacetic acids, trihalomethanes, and other DBPs
• Improves taste and odor issues common in heavily treated surface water
• Provides a first-line defense against organic contaminants
• Most effectively implemented as carbon block rather than loose granular activated carbon

Reverse OsmosisFor comprehensive protection, reverse osmosis technology offers superior reduction of a wide range of contaminants:

• Highly effective against disinfection byproducts that carbon filtration might miss
• Substantially reduces chromium-6, fluoride, and dissolved minerals
• Creates a multi-barrier approach when combined with carbon filtration
• Particularly recommended for households with young children, pregnant women, or immunocompromised individuals

Specialized Lead ReductionFor homes concerned about lead, particularly older construction with potential lead solder or service lines:

• NSF-certified lead reduction filters
• Point-of-use filters installed at taps used for drinking and cooking
• Regular testing to verify effectiveness

For Private Well Users (Trinity Aquifer)

Water Softening/Ion ExchangeCritical for addressing the increasing salinity issues in the Trinity Aquifer:

• Reduces hardness minerals and certain dissolved solids
• Helps prevent scale buildup in plumbing and appliances
• Improves effectiveness of soaps and detergents

Reverse OsmosisRecommended for comprehensive treatment of potential salt contamination:

• Effective against the specific salinity concerns of the Trinity Aquifer
• Provides multi-contaminant reduction
• Creates high-quality drinking water regardless of aquifer fluctuations

Regular Testing ProtocolMore frequent testing is essential for private well owners in Plano due to changing aquifer conditions:

• Quarterly testing for basic parameters
• Annual comprehensive testing including specific minerals and contaminants
• Testing should focus on salinity, mineral content, and potential contamination specific to the Trinity Aquifer

A comprehensive water quality solution for Plano residents should address both the immediate contaminant concerns and provide long-term protection against changing water conditions. The combination of activated carbon, reverse osmosis, and specialized treatment technologies offers the most complete protection against Plano's identified water quality challenges, whether you're on municipal water or a private well system.

‍